How Nokia lost the phone business, 2007 to 2013
2007 to 2013 · Last updated
Nokia was the world's largest phone maker when Apple unveiled the iPhone in 2007, but it kept betting on its Symbian software as touchscreen phones and Android gained ground. A 2011 switch to Windows Phone did not stop falling sales, and in September 2013, Nokia agreed to sell its phone business to Microsoft for €5.44 billion.[1][2][3][4][5]
Real moments
Hindsight puts you in the CEO's chair at each of these decisions, with only what was known at the time. See how your calls compare with what Nokia did and how other players chose.
Key figures
| Figure | Value | As of |
|---|---|---|
| Nokia's share of global mobile device sales | 36%[2] | 2006 |
| Price agreed for NAVTEQ | About $8.1 billion (€5.7 billion)[6] | October 1, 2007 |
| Nokia's share of smartphones | 38%, down from 52%[7] | 2008 |
| Nokia smart devices sold | 103.6 million[4] | 2010 |
| Nokia smart devices sold | 35.1 million[4] | 2012 |
| Nokia group operating loss | €2.3 billion[4] | 2012 |
| Nokia cash and other liquid assets | €9.9 billion[4] | End of 2012 |
| Price of the sale to Microsoft | €5.44 billion in cash[5][8] | September 3, 2013 |
| Nokia staff expected to move to Microsoft | About 32,000[5] | September 3, 2013 |
How big was Nokia when the iPhone came out?
Nokia was the largest maker of mobile devices in the world when Apple announced the iPhone on January 9, 2007. Its annual report for 2006 put its share of global device sales at 36%, a lead it had held since 1998. Symbian, the smartphone software Nokia backed, ran on 67% of smartphones shipped in 2006, according to Canalys figures.[2][9][1]
Apple priced the first iPhone at $499 for the 4GB model and $599 for the 8GB model, with sales in the US from June 2007.[1]
How did Nokia respond to the iPhone?
Nokia kept building keypad phones on Symbian and did not ship a mass-market touchscreen phone until late 2008. It announced the 5800 XpressMusic, a touchscreen Symbian phone, on October 2, 2008, for sale in the fourth quarter of that year.[10][1]
The higher-end N97 followed in 2009 and was widely criticized. In February 2010, Nokia executive Anssi Vanjoki called the N97 experience "a tremendous disappointment," and The Register's reviewer described the phone as rushed and buggy.[11][12]
Nokia also answered Apple's App Store. Apple's store opened with the iPhone 3G in July 2008 with more than 500 apps, while Nokia's Ovi Store opened on May 26, 2009, on more than 50 Nokia models.[13][14]
What did Nokia do with Symbian?
Nokia took full control of Symbian and set out to make it open source. On June 24, 2008, it offered €3.647 a share for the roughly 52% of Symbian Ltd it did not already own, and with partners it announced a Symbian Foundation to release the platform royalty-free.[15]
Nokia also worked on a second, Linux-based system. On February 15, 2010, Nokia and Intel merged their Maemo and Moblin projects into one platform called MeeGo.[16]
Inside Nokia, leaders defended Symbian against Android. In September 2010, Vanjoki compared phone makers that switched to Android to boys who wet their pants to stay warm in a Finnish winter, a remark widely reported at the time.[17][18]
Why did Nokia lose the smartphone market?
Nokia lost the smartphone market as rival platforms won buyers away from Symbian, and Nokia's own filings put its falling smartphone sales down to their momentum. Apple's iPhone arrived in 2007, Android was announced with the Open Handset Alliance on November 5, 2007, and the first Android phone, the T-Mobile G1, went on sale in October 2008.[4][19][20][21]
Nokia's own share of smartphones was already falling. Its 2008 annual report showed that share dropping from 52% to 38%, even as it still called S60 on Symbian the leading smartphone platform.[7]
Android's founding partners included phone makers such as Samsung, LG, Motorola and HTC, so Nokia faced many rivals on one free platform at once.[19]
Who replaced Nokia's CEO in 2010?
Stephen Elop, head of Microsoft's Business Division, replaced Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo as Nokia's president and CEO. The board announced the change on September 10, 2010, and Elop took over on September 21, 2010.[22]
Elop was the first person from outside Finland to lead Nokia, a point reporters stressed when he arrived.[23][24]
Why did Nokia choose Windows Phone over Android?
Nokia chose Windows Phone over Android because, CEO Stephen Elop said, it would have been hard for Nokia to stand out on Android. In February 2011, Nokia and Microsoft announced a partnership that made Windows Phone Nokia's "principal smartphone strategy." Gizmodo reported that Android had been considered and turned down.[3][25]
The announcement came days after Elop's "burning platform" memo to staff leaked around February 9, 2011. In it, Elop wrote that Android had just taken Nokia's lead in smartphone volumes.[26][3]
Nokia's first Windows Phone, the Lumia 800, went on sale in the UK on November 16, 2011.[27][28]
What happened to Nokia's sales after the switch to Windows Phone?
Nokia's smartphone sales kept falling after the switch. Its smart-device volumes fell from 103.6 million units in 2010 to 77.3 million in 2011 and 35.1 million in 2012.[4]
The decline came after the February 2011 announcement, but Nokia's filings blamed the strength of rival platforms against Symbian rather than the announcement itself. In 2012, the group reported net sales of €30.2 billion and an operating loss of €2.3 billion.[4]
Nokia pushed hard to sell Lumia phones. It backed a large US launch of the Lumia 900 with AT&T in April 2012, including a Times Square event. Later, the low-cost Lumia 520 became the most used Windows Phone, a position it still held in January 2016.[29][30][31][32]
When did Nokia sell its phone business to Microsoft?
Nokia agreed on September 3, 2013, to sell its phone business to Microsoft. Microsoft agreed to pay €5.44 billion in cash: €3.79 billion for substantially all of the Devices & Services business and €1.65 billion to license Nokia's patents.[5][8]
About 32,000 Nokia employees were expected to move to Microsoft, about 4,700 of them in Finland. Nokia kept its networks business, its HERE maps unit and its Advanced Technologies group, and carried on as a telecom-networks company.[5][8]
The decisions, one by one
-
Q1 2007
A rival unveils a touchscreen phone
What Nokia did It's a toy. Stay the course.
Kept faith in keypads and Symbian. Its first mass-market touchscreen phone arrived in late 2008.[10][1]
-
Q3 2007
Buy a digital-map company for ~$8B?
What Nokia did Buy it. Maps are the future.
Agreed to buy NAVTEQ for about $8.1 billion (announced October 2007).[6]
-
Q4 2007
A free, open phone OS is announced
What Nokia did Ignore it. Symbian is our moat.
-
Q2 2008
Open-source your aging OS?
What Nokia did Buy out partners, open-source it.
Agreed to buy out its partners in Symbian and set up a foundation to open-source it (June 2008).[15]
-
Q3 2008
A rival's app store opens
What Nokia did Build our own store, 70/30 split.
Opened its own Ovi Store in May 2009, nearly a year later.[14][13]
-
Q4 2008
Get a touchscreen phone to market
Launched the 5800 XpressMusic on Symbian in late 2008. The rushed N97 followed in 2009 and drew heavy criticism.[10][11][12]
-
Q1 2009
Keep your OS or replace it?
What Nokia did Keep Symbian and retrofit touch.
Stayed on Symbian and kept retrofitting it for touch. In 2010 a senior Nokia executive likened switching to Android to a boy wetting his pants to keep warm in winter.[11][18][17]
-
Q4 2009
Sue a rival over patents?
What Nokia did Sue them.
Sued Apple in October 2009. Apple agreed to pay royalties in a 2011 settlement.[33][34]
-
Q1 2010
A chip giant proposes a merged OS
Merged its Maemo OS with Intel’s Moblin to form MeeGo (February 2010).[16]
-
Q3 2010
The board reviews your job
Replaced its CEO in September 2010 with Stephen Elop, who came from Microsoft. He was the first non-Finn to run the company.[22][23][24]
-
Q1 2011
A software giant offers billions to switch OS
Chose Windows Phone in February 2011, days after the new CEO's “burning platform” memo. Symbian sales fell sharply after the announcement.[3][26][4]
-
Q1 2012
Fight for shelf space
Backed a big US launch of the Lumia 900 with AT&T in April 2012. The cheap Lumia 520 later became the most used Windows Phone.[29][30][31][32]
-
Q1 2013
Sell the phone business?
Agreed in September 2013 to sell its phone business to Microsoft for €5.44 billion. Nokia survived as a telecom-networks company.[5][8]
Timeline
- Jan 2007 Apple unveils the iPhone. Nokia is the world’s largest phone maker, and Symbian leads smartphones.[1][2][9]
- Oct 2007 Nokia agrees to buy NAVTEQ for about $8.1 billion.[6]
- Nov 2007 Google announces Android and the Open Handset Alliance.[19]
- Jun 2008 Nokia moves to take full control of Symbian and open-source it.[15]
- Jul 2008 Apple’s App Store opens.[13]
- Oct 2008 The first Android phone goes on sale.[20][21]
- 2009 Nokia’s Ovi Store opens. The touchscreen N97 draws heavy criticism.[14][11][12]
- Feb 2010 Nokia and Intel merge their Linux projects into MeeGo.[16]
- Sep 2010 Stephen Elop, from Microsoft, becomes CEO.[22]
- Feb 2011 The “burning platform” memo. Nokia picks Windows Phone. Symbian sales fall sharply.[26][3][4]
- Nov 2011 The first Lumia phones go on sale.[27][28]
- Sep 2013 Microsoft agrees to buy Nokia’s phone business for €5.44 billion.[5][8]
Questions people ask
Did Nokia ever make an Android phone during this period?
No. Nokia stayed on Symbian and then picked Windows Phone in February 2011, passing over Android.[3][25]
What was the burning platform memo?
It was an internal memo from CEO Stephen Elop that leaked around February 9, 2011. It warned staff that Nokia was falling behind Apple and Android, and it came days before the Windows Phone deal.[26][3]
Why did Nokia sue Apple?
Nokia sued Apple in Delaware on October 22, 2009, over ten patents covering GSM, UMTS and wireless LAN technology. On June 14, 2011, the two companies signed a patent license that settled the case, with Apple making a one-time payment and paying ongoing royalties.[33][34]
Why did Nokia buy NAVTEQ?
Nokia agreed on October 1, 2007, to buy the digital map maker NAVTEQ for $78 a share, about $8.1 billion, to build up its navigation and location services.[6]
What was the first Nokia Lumia phone?
The Lumia 800 was Nokia's first Windows Phone. It went on sale in the UK on November 16, 2011.[27][28]
Did Nokia go out of business after selling its phones?
No. Nokia kept its networks, HERE maps and Advanced Technologies businesses after the 2013 sale. It also had €9.9 billion in cash and other liquid assets at the end of 2012.[8][4]
How many people worked at Nokia before the sale?
Nokia had 97,798 employees at the end of 2012.[4]
Sources
- Apple reinvents the phone with iPhone, Apple, 2007-01-09 Primary source
- Nokia annual report on Form 20-F for 2006, Nokia (SEC filing), 2007-03-12 Primary source
- Nokia and Microsoft announce plans for a broad strategic partnership to build a new global mobile ecosystem, Microsoft, 2011-02-10 Primary source
- Nokia annual report on Form 20-F for 2012, Nokia (SEC filing), 2013-03-07 Primary source
- Microsoft to acquire Nokia's devices & services business, license Nokia's patents and mapping services, Microsoft, 2013-09-03 Primary source
- Nokia to acquire NAVTEQ (joint press release, NAVTEQ Form 8-K exhibit 99.1), NAVTEQ and Nokia (SEC filing), 2007-10-01 Primary source
- Nokia annual report on Form 20-F for 2008, Nokia (SEC filing), 2009-03-05 Primary source
- Nokia to sell Devices & Services business to Microsoft in EUR 5.44 billion all-cash transaction (Form 6-K), Nokia (SEC filing), 2013-09-03 Primary source
- Symbian worldwide smartphone share up to 67% (Canalys figures for 2006), All About Symbian, 2007-02-11
- Nokia amps up music offering with new Nokia 5800 XpressMusic (Form 6-K), Nokia (SEC filing), 2008-10-02 Primary source
- Nokia No.2 is so sorry for N97 debacle, The Register, 2010-02-25
- Nokia concedes the N97 seriously missed the mark, IT Pro, 2010-02-24
- iPhone 3G on sale tomorrow, Apple, 2008-07-10 Primary source
- Ovi Store opens for business (Form 6-K), Nokia (SEC filing), 2009-05-26 Primary source
- Nokia to acquire Symbian Limited to enable evolution of the leading open mobile platform (Form 6-K), Nokia (SEC filing), 2008-06-24 Primary source
- Intel and Nokia merge software platforms for future computing devices, Intel, 2010-02-15 Primary source
- Nokia exec: using Android is like peeing in your pants for warmth, The Next Web, 2010-09-21
- Nokia EVP Anssi Vanjoki: switching to Android is like peeing in your pants for warmth, TechCrunch, 2010-09-22
- Industry leaders announce open platform for mobile devices, Open Handset Alliance, 2007-11-05 Primary source
- T-Mobile G1 is now available, Android source code released, GSMArena, 2008-10-22
- T-Mobile G1 gets priced & dated, TechCrunch, 2008-09-23
- Nokia appoints Stephen Elop to President and CEO as of September 21, 2010 (Form 6-K), Nokia (SEC filing), 2010-09-10 Primary source
- Nokia's new CEO has a mobile mountain to climb, TechCrunch, 2010-09-10
- Outsider Elop invited to Nokia's inner circle, The National, 2010-10-15
- Why didn't Nokia use Android? Because that would be giving up, Gizmodo, 2011-02-12
- Nokia's 'burning platform' memo, Light Reading, 2011-02-09
- Lumia 800 to hit the UK on November 16th, Nokia confirms, Engadget, 2011-11-01
- Nokia Lumia 800 hits UK shelves, SlashGear, 2011-11-16
- Nokia takes over Times Square for Lumia 900 launch event, Engadget, 2012-04-07
- The ad budget for the Lumia 900 practically guarantees a ludicrous per-unit investment, The Next Web, 2012-04-09
- Our Windows Phone of 2013: the Nokia Lumia 520, MSPowerUser, 2013-12-31
- The three-year-old Nokia Lumia 520 is still the most popular Windows Phone smartphone, Digital Trends, 2016-01-29
- Nokia sues Apple in Delaware (Form 6-K), Nokia (SEC filing), 2009-10-22 Primary source
- Nokia enters into patent license agreement with Apple (Form 6-K), Nokia (SEC filing), 2011-06-14 Primary source