Company histories

Netscape and the browser war, 1994 to 1999

Netscape made Navigator, the most used web browser of the mid-1990s, and went public in August 1995. Microsoft then gave away Internet Explorer with Windows, and Navigator's share and sales fell. Netscape made its browser free in January 1998, published the code through mozilla.org, and agreed that November to be bought by AOL for stock valued at $4.2 billion.[1][2][3][4][5]

Real moments

Hindsight puts you in the CEO's chair at each of these decisions, with only what was known at the time. See how your calls compare with what Netscape did and how other players chose.

Play this decision

Key figures

FigureValueAs of
Business price of Navigator 1.0$39[6]December 15, 1994
IPO price$28 a share[2][7]August 8, 1995
First-day closing price$58.25[2][7][8]August 1995
Net IPO proceeds$148.2 million[2]August 1995
Browser license revenue$197.5 million (57% of revenue)[2]1996
Revenue$346.2 million[2]1996
Net loss$115.5 million[9][10]1997
AOL purchase price, at signing$4.2 billion in AOL stock[5][11]November 24, 1998
Value of the AOL deal at closingAbout $10 billion[12][13]March 17, 1999
Microsoft's settlement payment to AOL Time Warner$750 million[14]May 2003

Why did Netscape lose the browser war?

Netscape lost the browser war mainly because Microsoft gave Internet Explorer away and put it in front of users through Windows, a route to users that the court found no other channel came close to[1]. Microsoft never charged for its browser, the court found, and Netscape was eventually forced to stop charging too[1][3].

The court found that Microsoft spent more than $100 million a year on its browser from 1995 and grew its browser team from five or six people to more than a thousand[1]. On March 12, 1996, AOL picked Internet Explorer for its main online service, a day after choosing Navigator for its much smaller internet service[1].

By Netscape's own account in early 1999, Windows, with Microsoft's browser built in, shipped on about 95% of new PCs[10]. The court found Navigator's share of browser use fell to around 50% by late summer 1998, even as the number of people using it kept growing[1].

What did Microsoft propose to Netscape in June 1995?

At a meeting on June 21, 1995, Microsoft proposed that Netscape build its Windows 95 browser on Microsoft's own web technology and leave most browsing on Windows 95 to Microsoft, and Netscape did not agree, according to the court's findings[1]. The Justice Department later described the proposal as an offer to divide the browser market[15]. Microsoft disputed this account at trial[1].

The court found that Microsoft then held back a technical interface Netscape needed until late October 1995. As a result, Netscape shipped its Windows 95 browser well after Windows 95 itself and missed most of the holiday season[1].

A month before the meeting, in May 1995, Bill Gates's memo "The Internet Tidal Wave" had named Netscape as a new competitor[1]. The court judged it unclear whether Netscape could have survived as an independent business had it accepted the proposal[1].

How did the Netscape IPO go?

Netscape priced its initial public offering at $28 a share on August 8, 1995, and the stock closed its first day of trading at $58.25[2][7][8]. That close valued the company at nearly $3 billion, and the sale brought in net proceeds of $148.2 million[2][7].

The company had been founded in April 1994 and had not yet made a profit[16]. Its revenue for the first half of 1995 was $16.6 million[7][2]. Windows 95 and Internet Explorer launched the same month[1].

Did Netscape charge for its browser?

Yes, for businesses, until January 1998. When Navigator 1.0 shipped on December 15, 1994, Netscape set the price for business use at $39 and let schools, nonprofits and people evaluating it download it free[6]. The October 1994 test version had been free to individual, academic and research users[17].

Browser licenses were Netscape's largest business at first. They brought in $52.5 million of its $85.4 million revenue in 1995, and $197.5 million, or 57%, of its $346.2 million revenue in 1996[2]. Netscape made a net profit of $20.9 million in 1996[2].

On January 22, 1998, Netscape made Navigator and its Communicator suite free for all users[3]. By the fourth quarter of 1997, standalone browser sales had already fallen to about 13% of revenue, from about 45% a year earlier[18][3].

Why did Netscape turn to corporate software and Netcenter?

Netscape shifted toward businesses and its web site as browser income shrank. Software and services for businesses rose from 7% of its revenue in 1995 to 41% in 1996 and 62% in 1997[9]. In January 1998, its chief executive said Netscape would "accelerate our transition to an enterprise software company"[18].

Revenue grew to $533.9 million in 1997, but Netscape lost $115.5 million that year[10][9]. In January 1998, it cut about 400 jobs[9].

Netscape opened its Netcenter portal in September 1997[19]. In April 1998, Excite prepaid $70 million and issued warrants to program search and several channels on Netcenter for two years, and Netscape relaunched the portal in June 1998[20][10][19]. Web site revenue was 17.8% of the total in 1997 and 26.9% in the ten months to October 1998[9][10].

When did Netscape release its browser source code?

Netscape released the source code of its next browser through mozilla.org on March 31, 1998[4][21]. It had announced the plan on January 22, 1998, the same day it made the browser free[3].

At the time, Netscape claimed an installed base of more than 68 million users and about 90% of the education market, where its browser was already free[3].

In December 1998, Netscape delivered Gecko, a new browsing engine and its first product built with contributions through mozilla.org[10].

When did AOL buy Netscape, and for how much?

AOL agreed on November 24, 1998, to buy Netscape for 0.45 AOL shares for each Netscape share, a deal valued at $4.2 billion[5][11]. The purchase closed on March 17, 1999, when AOL's higher share price had lifted its value to about $10 billion[12][13].

Alongside the deal, AOL formed a three-year alliance with Sun Microsystems. Sun was to pay AOL more than $350 million in fees over three years, and AOL agreed to buy $500 million of Sun systems[5].

In August 1999, AOL reported that Netcenter had more than 17 million registered users[22].

What did the Microsoft antitrust case find about Netscape?

In its Findings of Fact of November 5, 1999, the court found that Microsoft had harmed Netscape's business in order to protect Windows[1]. The court also found that Navigator became the main way Sun's Java reached Windows PCs, a kind of software Microsoft saw as a threat to Windows[1].

The Justice Department and 20 states sued Microsoft on May 18, 1998, citing among other things its 1995 proposal to Netscape[15]. Jim Barksdale, Netscape's chief executive, was the government's first witness when the trial opened in October 1998[23][24].

The court approved the government's settlement with Microsoft in November 2002[25]. In May 2003, Microsoft paid AOL Time Warner $750 million to settle the suit AOL had filed on Netscape's behalf[14].

The decisions, one by one

  1. Dec 1994

    Charge for the browser, or give it away?

    What Netscape did Charge businesses $39 a copy.

    Netscape set the price of Navigator 1.0 for business use at $39 on December 15, 1994, and kept it free to download for schools, nonprofits and evaluation. Its October test version had been free to individuals.[6][17]

  2. Spring 1995

    Ship a partner's new language in our browser?

    What Netscape did License it for every copy.

    Netscape agreed in May 1995 to ship Sun's Java with every copy of Navigator, and in December 1995 the two announced JavaScript, backed by 28 companies. The court later found Navigator became the main way Java reached Windows PCs.[1][26][27]

  3. Jun 1995

    Accept the software giant's partnership?

    What Netscape did Refuse, and ship our own.

    At a meeting on June 21, 1995, Microsoft proposed that Netscape build its Windows 95 browser on Microsoft's web technology and leave most browsing to Microsoft; Netscape did not agree. The court found Microsoft then held back technical information until late October. Microsoft disputed this account.[1][15]

  4. Aug 1995

    Go public without a profit?

    What Netscape did Go public.

    Netscape priced its shares at $28 on August 8, 1995. On the first day of trading they closed at $58.25, valuing the company at nearly $3 billion. Net proceeds were $148.2 million.[2][7][8]

  5. Early 1996

    Keep charging against a free rival?

    Netscape kept charging for its browser until January 1998. Browser licenses brought in $197.5 million, 57% of its 1996 revenue. The court found Microsoft never charged for its browser, and that Netscape was eventually forced to follow.[2][1][3]

  6. Early 1997

    Become a corporate software company?

    What Netscape did Go after corporate customers.

    Netscape went corporate: software and services for businesses rose from 7% of its revenue in 1995 to 41% in 1996 and 62% in 1997. In January 1998 its chief executive said it would speed up its move to become an enterprise software company.[9][18]

  7. Jan 1998

    Publish the browser's source code?

    What Netscape did Publish the code.

    On January 22, 1998, Netscape made its browser free for all users and said it would publish the source code of the next version. It released the code through mozilla.org on March 31, 1998.[3][4][21]

  8. Spring 1998

    Build the portal with a search partner?

    What Netscape did Take the $70 million partner.

    Netscape signed a two-year deal with Excite in April 1998: Excite prepaid $70 million, gave warrants and programmed search and several channels. Netscape relaunched Netcenter in June 1998 and began keeping visitors on its own pages.[20][10][19]

  9. Late 1998

    Sell to the biggest online service?

    What Netscape did Sell to America Online.

    Netscape agreed on November 24, 1998, to be bought by AOL for 0.45 AOL shares each, valued at $4.2 billion, as AOL formed a three-year alliance with Sun. The deal closed on March 17, 1999, worth about $10 billion by then.[5][11][12][13]

Timeline

  1. Oct 1994 Netscape offers a test version of its browser free to individual, academic and research users.[17]
  2. Dec 1994 Navigator 1.0 ships. The price for business use is $39; schools, nonprofits and people evaluating it download it free.[6]
  3. Jan 1995 James Barksdale becomes president and chief executive; co-founder James Clark stays chairman.[16]
  4. May 1995 Bill Gates's memo "The Internet Tidal Wave" calls Netscape a new competitor. Netscape agrees to ship Sun's Java with Navigator.[1][26]
  5. Jun 1995 At a meeting on June 21, Microsoft proposes a "special relationship"; Netscape does not agree, the court later finds.[1][15]
  6. Aug 1995 Netscape goes public at $28 a share and closes the first day at $58.25. Windows 95 and Internet Explorer launch the same month.[2][7][8][1]
  7. Dec 1995 Netscape and Sun announce JavaScript, backed by 28 companies.[27]
  8. Mar 1996 AOL picks Internet Explorer for its main service, a day after choosing Navigator for its much smaller internet service.[1]
  9. 1996 Revenue reaches $346 million with a $21 million profit; the browser brings in 57% of it.[2]
  10. Late 1996 Internet Explorer 3.0 wins reviews that rate it close to Navigator.[1]
  11. Sep 1997 Netscape opens its Netcenter portal.[19]
  12. 1997 Revenue grows to $534 million, but Netscape loses $115.5 million; corporate software is 62% of revenue.[10][9]
  13. Jan 1998 Navigator becomes free for everyone, Netscape promises to publish its source code, and about 400 jobs are cut.[3][9]
  14. Mar 1998 The browser source code goes online through mozilla.org.[4][21]
  15. Apr 1998 Excite prepays $70 million to program search and channels on Netcenter for two years.[20]
  16. May 1998 The Justice Department and 20 states sue Microsoft.[15]
  17. Oct 1998 Barksdale is the government's first witness at the trial.[23][24]
  18. Nov 1998 AOL agrees to buy Netscape for stock valued at $4.2 billion, and forms an alliance with Sun.[5][11]
  19. Dec 1998 Netscape delivers Gecko, its first engine built with contributions through mozilla.org.[10]
  20. Mar 1999 The AOL deal closes, worth about $10 billion after AOL's shares rose.[12][13]
  21. Aug 1999 AOL reports that Netcenter has more than 17 million registered users.[22]
  22. Nov 1999 The court's Findings of Fact say Microsoft harmed Netscape's business in protecting Windows.[1]
  23. Nov 2002 The court approves the government's settlement with Microsoft.[25]
  24. May 2003 Microsoft pays AOL Time Warner $750 million to settle the suit filed on Netscape's behalf.[14]

Questions people ask

Who founded Netscape?

James Clark and Marc Andreessen co-founded Netscape in April 1994[16]. Andreessen had co-written NCSA Mosaic, an earlier browser[17].

Who ran Netscape?

James Barksdale became president and chief executive in January 1995, and co-founder James Clark stayed on as chairman[16]. Barksdale led Netscape until AOL bought it in 1999[16][11].

When was Netscape Navigator 1.0 released?

Netscape shipped Navigator 1.0 on December 15, 1994[6]. A free test version had come out on October 13, 1994[17].

Did Netscape create JavaScript?

Netscape and Sun Microsystems announced JavaScript on December 4, 1995, with backing from 28 companies[27]. Earlier, in May 1995, Netscape had agreed to ship Sun's Java with Navigator[26][1].

How many people worked at Netscape?

Netscape had 203 employees at the end of 1994[2]. It had about 2,310 in February 1998, after cutting about 400 jobs that January[9].

How many people used Netscape Navigator?

The court found Navigator's installed base in the US grew from 15 million in 1996 to 33 million in December 1998, even while its share fell[1]. In January 1998, Netscape claimed an installed base of more than 68 million users[3].

What was Gecko?

Gecko was a browsing engine Netscape delivered in December 1998, its first product built with contributions through mozilla.org[10].

Play this decision

Sources

  1. United States v. Microsoft: Court's Findings of Fact, US District Court for the District of Columbia (published by the Department of Justice), 1999-11-05 Primary source
  2. Netscape Communications annual report on Form 10-K for 1996, Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1997-03-28 Primary source
  3. Netscape Announces Plans to Make Next-Generation Communicator Source Code Available Free on the Net (Form 8-K, exhibit 99.1), Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1998-01-22 Primary source
  4. Netscape Accelerates Communicator Evolution with First Release of Next-Generation Communicator Source Code to Developer Community via mozilla.org, Netscape Communications (press release, Wayback Machine copy), 1998-03-31 Primary source
  5. America Online Form 8-K: agreement to acquire Netscape and strategic alliance with Sun Microsystems, America Online (SEC EDGAR), 1998-11-24 Primary source
  6. Netscape Communications Ships Release 1.0 of Netscape Navigator and Netscape Servers, Netscape Communications (press release, Wayback Machine copy), 1994-12-15 Primary source
  7. Netscape With a Bullet, TIME, 1995-08-09
  8. The IPO That Inflated the Dot-Com Bubble, The Motley Fool, 2013-08-09
  9. Netscape Communications annual report on Form 10-K for 1997, Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1998-03-27 Primary source
  10. Netscape Communications annual report on Form 10-K for the ten months ended October 31, 1998, Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1999-01-29 Primary source
  11. Netscape Communications Form 8-K on the merger agreement with America Online, Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1998-11-25 Primary source
  12. America Online Form 8-K: completion of the Netscape acquisition, America Online (SEC EDGAR), 1999-03-26 Primary source
  13. AOL completes Netscape acquisition after shareholder vote, Tech Monitor (Computer Business Review), 1999-03-17
  14. AOL Time Warner and Microsoft Agree to Collaborate on Digital Media Initiatives and Settle Pending Litigation, Microsoft, 2003-05-29 Primary source
  15. Justice Department Files Antitrust Suit Against Microsoft for Unlawfully Monopolizing Computer Software Markets, US Department of Justice, 1998-05-18 Primary source
  16. Netscape Communications proxy statement, 1997, Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1997-04-29 Primary source
  17. Netscape Communications Offers New Network Navigator Free on the Internet, Netscape Communications (press release, Wayback Machine copy), 1994-10-13 Primary source
  18. Netscape Announces Preliminary Fourth Quarter Results (Form 8-K, exhibit 99.1), Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1998-01-05 Primary source
  19. Netscape Communications quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended July 31, 1998, Netscape Communications (SEC EDGAR), 1998-09-14 Primary source
  20. Excite, Inc. annual report on Form 10-K for 1998, Excite, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 1999-02-09 Primary source
  21. Freeing the Source: The Story of Mozilla, O'Reilly Media (Open Sources, by Netscape's Jim Hamerly and Tom Paquin), 1999-01
  22. America Online annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended June 30, 1999, America Online (SEC EDGAR), 1999-08-13 Primary source
  23. Direct Testimony of Jim Barksdale: U.S. v. Microsoft Corporation; State of New York v. Microsoft Corporation, US Department of Justice, Antitrust Division, 1998-10 Primary source
  24. The Microsoft Case: trial summaries, Berkman Center for Internet & Society, Harvard Law School, 1998
  25. Statement on the court's approval of the Microsoft settlement, US Department of Justice, 2002-11-01 Primary source
  26. Netscape adopts Sun's Java language for Navigator, Tech Monitor (Computer Business Review), 1995-05-25
  27. Netscape and Sun Announce JavaScript, the Open, Cross-Platform Object Scripting Language for Enterprise Networks and the Internet, Netscape Communications (press release, Wayback Machine copy), 1995-12-04 Primary source