Company histories

Netflix, Qwikster and the 2011 price change

Qwikster was the planned new name for Netflix's DVD-by-mail service, announced on September 18, 2011, after a July price change raised the cost of DVDs plus streaming from $9.99 to $15.98 a month. Netflix dropped Qwikster on October 10, 2011, kept the new prices and lost about 800,000 US members that quarter.[1][2][3][4]

Real moments

Hindsight puts you in the CEO's chair at each of these decisions, with only what was known at the time. See how your calls compare with what Netflix did and how other players chose.

Play this decision

Key figures

FigureValueAs of
Price for DVDs plus streaming before the change$9.99 a month[2][5]July 2011
Price for DVDs plus streaming after the change$15.98 a month[2][5]September 1, 2011, for existing members
Price of each separate plan$7.99 a month[2]July 12, 2011
US members24.59 million[6]June 30, 2011
US members23.79 million[4]September 30, 2011
US members lost in one quarterAbout 800,000[4][7]Third quarter of 2011
Capital raised$400 million[8][9]November 21, 2011
Net loss$5 million[10]First quarter of 2012
US streaming membersOver 27 million[11]End of 2012

What was Qwikster?

Qwikster was the brand Netflix planned for its DVD-by-mail service, which would have become a separate business with its own website. Reed Hastings announced it on the company blog on September 18, 2011, while streaming would keep the Netflix name[1][12].

The two websites would not have shared queues or ratings, so members who used both services would have managed them in two places with two bills. Andy Rendich was named to lead Qwikster[1][13].

The same blog post apologized for how Netflix had handled its price change that summer[1][13].

How much did Netflix raise its prices in 2011?

Netflix raised the price of DVDs plus streaming from $9.99 to $15.98 a month, a rise of up to 60%. It announced on July 12, 2011, that unlimited streaming and one DVD at a time by mail would become separate plans at $7.99 each[2][5].

The new prices applied at once for new members and from September 1, 2011, for existing ones[2][6].

A streaming-only plan had cost $7.99 since November 2010, and nearly three in four new members were choosing it. Netflix ended June 2011 with about 24.6 million US members[6].

Why did Netflix split DVD and streaming into separate plans?

Netflix began running DVD by mail and streaming as two separate businesses. The July 2011 announcement gave the DVD service its own management team under Andy Rendich[2][6].

Netflix expected the change to cost it members. Its second-quarter letter, dated July 25, 2011, said some subscribers would cancel[6].

After the losses came in, Netflix said in October 2011 that its mistake was moving too fast, not the direction it had chosen[4].

Why did Netflix cancel Qwikster?

Netflix canceled Qwikster on October 10, 2011, three weeks after announcing it, so that members could keep DVDs and streaming on one website with one account[3][14].

The separate prices did not change[3][15]. By then the shares had lost more than half their value since July, and they rose about 4% in early trading after the news[14][15].

How many subscribers did Netflix lose after the price hike?

Netflix lost about 800,000 US members in the third quarter of 2011, its first quarterly decline. Its US members fell from 24.59 million at the end of June to 23.79 million at the end of September[4][7].

Of those members, 21.4 million had streaming and 13.9 million had DVD plans. On September 15, 2011, Netflix had already cut its quarter-end forecast to 21.8 million streaming and 14.2 million DVD members[4][16][17].

Reports of the share fall differ. AP reported a drop of more than 26% in after-hours trading on October 24, 2011, while Yahoo Finance reported a fall of about 35% in trading the next day[7][18].

What happened between Netflix and Starz in 2011?

Starz said on September 1, 2011, that it had ended talks to renew its streaming deal with Netflix, citing the pricing and packaging of its content[19][20].

The deal gave Netflix about 1,000 films and was estimated at about $30 million a year. Netflix said it would spend the money it had set aside for Starz with other providers[20][21].

The Starz films left Netflix when the deal expired at the end of February 2012[10].

How did Netflix recover after Qwikster?

Netflix raised $400 million in November 2011 and launched in the UK and Ireland on January 9, 2012[8][9][22]. It posted a $5 million loss in the first quarter of 2012 and returned to profit in the second, with $6 million of net income[10][23].

In July 2012, Netflix said it expected full recovery of its brand to take about three years[23].

By the end of 2012, Netflix had over 27 million US streaming members and over 6 million abroad. It reported a profit for 2012, and its shares rose 42% on January 24, 2013[11][24].

How did House of Cards fit into Netflix's comeback?

House of Cards was Netflix's biggest bet on its own series after the 2011 crisis. Netflix had outbid HBO for it in March 2011, committing about $100 million for 26 episodes[25][26].

On October 4, 2012, Netflix said all 13 episodes of the first season would be available at once on February 1, 2013, in every country it served[27][28].

It had already released all eight episodes of Lilyhammer, its first original series, at once in February 2012[9][10].

The decisions, one by one

  1. Jul 2011

    Split discs and streaming, and raise the price for everyone at once?

    What Netflix did Split the plans. Everyone by September.

    Netflix announced on July 12, 2011, that it would split streaming and DVD by mail into separate $7.99 plans. Members who wanted both would pay $15.98 instead of $9.99, a rise of up to 60%, from September 1 for existing members.[2][6][5]

  2. Aug 2011

    Pay whatever it takes to keep the premium channel's films?

    What Netflix did Let it lapse; spend elsewhere.

    Starz said on September 1, 2011, that it had ended renewal talks with Netflix, citing the pricing and packaging of its content. Its films left Netflix when the deal expired at the end of February 2012.[19][20][21][10]

  3. Jan 2012

    Open in the UK and Ireland, knowing it means a loss this year?

    What Netflix did Launch now.

    Netflix launched in the UK and Ireland on January 9, 2012, at £5.99 and €6.99 a month. It expected losses for 2012 and said it would open no more new countries until it was profitable again. It posted a $5 million loss in the first quarter of 2012.[22][29][9][10]

  4. Oct 2012

    Release a whole season on one day?

    What Netflix did Release all 13 episodes at once.

    Netflix announced on October 4, 2012, that all 13 episodes of House of Cards would be available at once on February 1, 2013, in every country it served. It had outbid HBO in March 2011 with a commitment of about $100 million for 26 episodes.[27][28][30][25][26]

  5. Nov 2012

    Adopt a rights plan against the activist, or hear out buyers?

    What Netflix did Adopt the rights plan.

    Carl Icahn disclosed a 9.98% position on October 31, 2012, saying Netflix could be valuable to larger companies. On November 2 the board adopted a rights plan triggered at 10% (20% for some institutions), announced on November 5 and set to run until 2015.[31][32][33]

  6. Dec 2012

    Pay for a major studio's new films, starting in 2016?

    What Netflix did Sign the exclusive deal.

    Netflix and Disney announced on December 4, 2012, a multi-year deal making Netflix the exclusive US subscription TV home for Disney, Pixar, Marvel and Disneynature films from the 2016 releases. Terms were not disclosed. Netflix shares rose 14% that day.[34][35][11]

Timeline

  1. Mar 2011 Netflix outbids HBO for House of Cards, committing about $100 million for 26 episodes.[25][26]
  2. Jul 2011 Netflix splits streaming and DVD into separate $7.99 plans: $15.98 for both instead of $9.99. The shares trade near $305.[2][5][36]
  3. Sep 2011 Starz ends renewal talks (September 1). Netflix cuts its member forecast (September 15). Reed Hastings apologizes and announces Qwikster (September 18).[19][16][17][1][12]
  4. Oct 2011 Netflix drops Qwikster (October 10), then reports 800,000 fewer US members (October 24). The shares fall about 35% the next day.[3][14][4][7][18][37]
  5. Nov 2011 Netflix raises $400 million in stock and convertible notes.[8][38]
  6. Jan 2012 Netflix launches in the UK and Ireland.[22][29]
  7. Feb 2012 Starz films leave Netflix. Lilyhammer, its first original series, releases all eight episodes at once.[10][9]
  8. Jul 2012 Netflix returns to profit, with $6 million of net income in the second quarter.[23]
  9. Oct 2012 Netflix opens in Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, and sets February 1 for all of House of Cards.[30][27]
  10. Nov 2012 Carl Icahn discloses a 9.98% position; the board adopts a rights plan.[31][32][33]
  11. Dec 2012 Netflix signs an exclusive US pay-TV deal for Disney films from 2016.[34][35]
  12. Jan 2013 Netflix reports over 27 million US streaming members and a profit for 2012; the shares rise 42% in a day. It sells $500 million of bonds.[11][24][39][40]

Questions people ask

Who was Netflix's CEO during the Qwikster episode?

Reed Hastings was CEO. He wrote the September 18, 2011, blog post that apologized for the price change and announced Qwikster[1][13].

Would Qwikster have rented video games?

Yes. Netflix said Qwikster would add video game rentals to its DVD service[1][12].

Did Netflix lower its prices after dropping Qwikster?

No. When it called off Qwikster on October 10, 2011, Netflix kept the separate $7.99 plans for streaming and DVDs[3][15].

Who bought the $400 million of Netflix securities in 2011?

Technology Crossover Ventures bought $200 million of zero-coupon convertible notes[8]. Netflix also sold $200 million of stock, 2.86 million shares at $70, and called the money a safety net it did not plan to spend[9][38].

When did Netflix launch in the UK and Ireland?

Netflix launched in the UK and Ireland on January 9, 2012, at £5.99 and €6.99 a month[22][29]. It said it would open no more new countries until it was profitable again[9].

Did Carl Icahn buy Netflix shares after the crisis?

Yes. Carl Icahn disclosed a 9.98% position in Netflix on October 31, 2012[31]. The board adopted a rights plan on November 2, 2012, triggered at 10% ownership[32][33].

What deal did Netflix sign with Disney in 2012?

On December 4, 2012, Netflix and Disney announced a multi-year deal making Netflix the exclusive US subscription TV home for new Disney, Pixar, Marvel and Disneynature films, starting with the 2016 releases. Terms were not disclosed[34][35].

Play this decision

Sources

  1. An Explanation and Some Reflections (Netflix blog, archived copy), Netflix, 2011-09-18 Primary source
  2. Netflix Introduces New Plans and Announces Price Changes (Netflix blog, archived copy), Netflix, 2011-07-12 Primary source
  3. DVDs will be staying at netflix.com (Netflix blog, archived copy), Netflix, 2011-10-10 Primary source
  4. Letter to shareholders, third quarter 2011 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2011-10-24 Primary source
  5. Netflix raises DVD, streaming plan price by 60 pct (Reuters), Today.com, 2011-07-12
  6. Letter to shareholders, second quarter 2011 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2011-07-25 Primary source
  7. Netflix loses 800,000 subscribers in tough 3Q (AP), NBC News, 2011-10-24
  8. 8-K: note purchase agreement with Technology Crossover Ventures, Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2011-11-21 Primary source
  9. Letter to shareholders, fourth quarter 2011 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2012-01-25 Primary source
  10. Letter to shareholders, first quarter 2012 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2012-04-23 Primary source
  11. Letter to shareholders, fourth quarter 2012 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2013-01-23 Primary source
  12. Netflix splits into two companies, NPR, 2011-09-19
  13. Netflix's Reed Hastings says 'I messed up'; DVD unit will split, re-brand as Qwikster, Deadline, 2011-09-19
  14. Netflix drops plan to split business (AP), CBC News, 2011-10-10
  15. Netflix scuttles its 'Qwikster' DVD rental plan, NPR, 2011-10-10
  16. Letter to shareholders, September 15, 2011 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2011-09-15 Primary source
  17. Netflix cuts subscriber growth forecast, Telecompaper, 2011-09-15
  18. A 'spectacular collapse': Netflix loses 800,000 subscribers, stock plunges 35%, Yahoo Finance (The Daily Ticker), 2011-10-25
  19. Starz Entertainment issues statement on status of Netflix affiliation agreement renewal discussions, Starz (PR Newswire), 2011-09-01 Primary source
  20. Starz walks out on Netflix streaming talks, msnbc.com, 2011-09-01
  21. Starz nixes deal with Netflix, Variety, 2011-09-01
  22. Netflix launches in the United Kingdom and Ireland, Netflix (PR Newswire), 2012-01-09 Primary source
  23. Letter to shareholders, second quarter 2012 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2012-07-24 Primary source
  24. Netflix shares up 42 percent (AP), CBS News, 2013-01-24
  25. Netflix outbids HBO for David Fincher and Kevin Spacey's 'House of Cards', The Hollywood Reporter, 2011-03-15
  26. Netflix reportedly acquires original TV series 'House of Cards', ABC News, 2011-03-16
  27. Netflix original series House of Cards available exclusively on February 1, 2013, Netflix (PR Newswire), 2012-10-04 Primary source
  28. Netflix's 'House of Cards' set to premiere February 1, 2013, Deadline, 2012-10-04
  29. Netflix launches in Ireland and UK today, RTÉ News, 2012-01-09
  30. Letter to shareholders, third quarter 2012 (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2012-10-23 Primary source
  31. Schedule 13D on Netflix common stock (9.98%), Icahn Associates (SEC EDGAR), 2012-10-31 Primary source
  32. Netflix adopts stockholder rights plan (8-K exhibit 99.1), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2012-11-05 Primary source
  33. Netflix seeks to fend off Icahn with poison pill (Reuters), NBC News, 2012-11-05
  34. Netflix and The Walt Disney Studios announce multi-year premium pay TV window agreement in the United States, Netflix and Disney (PR Newswire), 2012-12-04 Primary source
  35. Disney inks exclusive deal with Netflix, Variety, 2012-12-04
  36. Netflix seeks to raise at least US$400m (AP), Jamaica Observer, 2011-11-22
  37. Netflix continues to reel, losing 800,000 subscribers, Rolling Stone, 2011-10-25
  38. Netflix raises $400 million for recovery, Radio & Television Business Report, 2011-11-22
  39. Annual report (10-K) for 2012, Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2013-02-01 Primary source
  40. Netflix announces pricing of $500 million senior notes offering (8-K exhibit 99.2), Netflix (SEC EDGAR), 2013-01-29 Primary source