JCPenney and the end of coupons, 2011 to 2013
2011 to 2013 · Last updated
JCPenney replaced coupons and hundreds of yearly promotions with Fair and Square everyday pricing in all its stores on February 1, 2012. Comparable store sales fell 25.2% in fiscal 2012, and the company lost $985 million. The board replaced CEO Ron Johnson on April 8, 2013, and sales and coupons returned.[1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8]
Real moments
Hindsight puts you in the CEO's chair at each of these decisions, with only what was known at the time. See how your calls compare with what JCPenney did and how other players chose.
Key figures
| Figure | Value | As of |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | $17.26 billion[4] | Fiscal 2011 |
| Sales | $12.99 billion, down 24.8%[5][4] | Fiscal 2012 |
| Net loss | $985 million[5][4] | Fiscal 2012 |
| Comparable store sales, first quarter | Down 18.9%[9] | First quarter 2012 |
| Comparable store sales, fourth quarter | Down 31.7%[5] | Fourth quarter 2012 |
| Sales per gross square foot | $154 in 2011, $116 in 2012[4] | Fiscal 2011 and 2012 |
| Cash at year end | $930 million[4] | End of fiscal 2012 |
| Capital spending | $810 million[10] | 2012 |
| Term loan secured on property | $2.25 billion[11] | May 22, 2013 |
Why did JCPenney's Fair and Square pricing fail?
JCPenney's shoppers bought far less once the coupons and frequent sales were gone, and the losses outran the company's cash and its board's patience[9][5][6]. Comparable store sales fell 18.9% in the first quarter of 2012, 21.7% in the second, 26.1% in the third and 31.7% in the fourth[9][12][13][5].
The company's own filings put store traffic down about 10% in the first quarter of 2012 and about 12% in the second[3][14]. Sales per gross square foot fell from $154 in fiscal 2011 to $116 in fiscal 2012[4].
The new pricing went live in every store on the same day, with no pilot first[2]. Two later accounts say a test in a few stores was suggested before launch and turned down[15][16].
What was JCPenney's Fair and Square pricing?
Fair and Square was a three-tier pricing plan that JCPenney announced in New York on January 25, 2012[1][17]. It had everyday prices, month-long values, and best prices on the first and third Fridays of each month[1][2].
The plan swapped hundreds of separate promotions for 12 monthly events a year[1][17]. ABC News reported that everyday prices would sit about 40% below 2011's tag prices[18][1].
The same event unveiled a new logo and a plan to fill each store with 80 to 100 brand shops[1][17]. Ron Johnson, who had run Apple's retail stores, had become CEO on November 1, 2011[19].
Did JCPenney test the new pricing before launching it?
No. JCPenney changed prices, signs, logo and advertising in all its stores at once on February 1, 2012[2].
Fortune and HuffPost both report that a trial in a small number of stores was proposed beforehand and rejected[15][16]. The two accounts differ on who proposed it: Fortune says a director, while HuffPost says an executive[15][16].
The company had about 1,100 stores at the time[1][4]. Its fourth-quarter 2011 results, released in February 2012, showed a gross margin cut by the markdowns taken to reset prices[20].
How much did JCPenney's sales fall in 2012?
JCPenney's sales fell 24.8% in fiscal 2012, to $12.99 billion, and it lost $985 million[5][4]. In fiscal 2011, sales had been $17.26 billion, with a net loss of $152 million[4].
Every quarter of 2012 lost money: $163 million in the first, $147 million in the second, $123 million in the third and $552 million in the fourth[9][12][13][5]. Cash fell from $1.51 billion at the end of fiscal 2011 to $930 million at the end of fiscal 2012[4].
To save money, the company planned $900 million of yearly cost cuts in April 2012 and ended its $0.20 quarterly dividend on May 15, 2012, which saved about $175 million a year[21][9][4].
What were JCPenney's brand shops?
The brand shops were small stores within each JCPenney store, set up for partner brands, and the first ones opened on August 1, 2012[1][14]. By November 2012, the company had converted 7.2 million square feet of selling space to shops[13].
In its third-quarter 2012 results, the CEO described JCPenney as a tale of two companies, with the new shops doing well while the rest of the store struggled[13]. Capital spending reached $810 million in 2012[10].
The rebuild went on after the CEO changed. A new home floor in 505 stores started in March 2013, and a new fashion shop went into nearly 700 stores[10][22].
When did JCPenney bring back coupons and sales?
JCPenney said on January 29, 2013, that it would bring back some sales and show 'compare at' prices next to its own, and ABC News reported that coupons were back by late February 2013[7][8].
After Ron Johnson left, the company's May 2013 quarterly filing described a move back to promotions on selected merchandise[22]. In May 2013, a JCPenney ad asked customers to come back[23][15].
In the summer of 2012, the company had already dropped the month-long values and lowered everyday prices[14][12].
When did Ron Johnson leave JCPenney?
Ron Johnson left JCPenney on April 8, 2013, about 17 months after he became CEO. The board named his predecessor, Myron Ullman, to replace him[6][24].
The company's release said Johnson was stepping down, while the Associated Press reported that the board ousted him[6][24].
Johnson had been named CEO in June 2011, after 11 years running Apple's retail business and 15 years at Target[19]. He bought $50 million of warrants on JCPenney stock when he was named[19].
How did JCPenney raise money after the pricing failure?
JCPenney borrowed against its property and then sold new shares. A $2.25 billion five-year term loan closed on May 22, 2013, secured by mortgages on the headquarters, distribution centers and some stores[25][11][4]. In September 2013, it sold 84 million new shares at $9.65 each[26].
Strain had shown earlier in 2013. Some bondholders sent a notice of default in February, which they withdrew in March[27].
Pershing Square, led by William Ackman, reported a 16.5% stake in October 2010, and Ackman joined the board in February 2011[28][29]. He left the board in August 2013, days after the board backed its chairman in a dispute with him, and Pershing Square sold all its shares that month[30][31][32].
The decisions, one by one
-
Dec 2011
Buy a stake in a lifestyle brand for its shops?
What JCPenney did Buy the stake for $38.5 million.
JCPenney bought 11 million new shares of Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, 16.6% of the company, for $38.5 million on December 6, 2011. Macy's, which held a 2006 deal with the brand, sued JCPenney in August 2012; the case was settled in 2017.[33][10][34]
-
Jan 2012
End coupons and sales for everyday prices?
What JCPenney did End coupons. Honest prices every day.
JCPenney announced Fair and Square pricing on January 25, 2012: everyday prices, month-long values and 'best prices' on the first and third Fridays, with 12 monthly events instead of hundreds of promotions.[1][2][17][18]
-
Nov 2012
Speed up the store rebuild, or slow it?
What JCPenney did Rebuild fast: home floor by spring.
By November 2012 JCPenney had turned 7.2 million square feet into brand shops, and it spent $810 million on capital projects that year. It kept going: the home floor in 505 stores was rebuilt from March 2013, and a new fashion shop went into nearly 700 stores.[13][10][22]
Timeline
- Oct 2010 Pershing Square reports a 16.5% stake and Vornado 9.9%; JCPenney adopts a one-year shareholder rights plan.[28][35][36]
- Feb 2011 William Ackman and Steven Roth join the board. A $900 million share buyback follows, finished in May.[29][2]
- Jun 2011 JCPenney names Ron Johnson, head of Apple's stores, its next CEO from November 1. He buys $50 million of warrants.[19]
- Nov 2011 Ron Johnson becomes CEO. Third-quarter comparable sales are down 1.6%, and cash is about $1.1 billion.[2][37]
- Dec 2011 JCPenney buys 16.6% of Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia for $38.5 million.[33]
- Jan 2012 Fair and Square pricing, a new logo and a plan for 80 to 100 brand shops per store are unveiled in New York.[1][17]
- Feb 2012 The new prices go live in every store on February 1. Fourth-quarter 2011 results show the cost of resetting prices.[2][20]
- Apr 2012 JCPenney plans $900 million of yearly cost cuts, from head office, stores and advertising.[21]
- May 2012 First-quarter comparable sales fall 18.9% and store traffic about 10%. The dividend is ended.[9][3]
- Jun 2012 President Michael Francis leaves after eight months.[38]
- Aug 2012 Month-long values are dropped and everyday prices cut. The first brand shops open on August 1. Macy's sues over the Martha Stewart deal.[14][10]
- Nov 2012 Third-quarter comparable sales fall 26.1%. The CEO calls the company 'a tale of two companies'.[13]
- Feb 2013 2012 sales fall to $12.99 billion, down 24.8%, with a $985 million loss. Some bondholders send a notice of default, later withdrawn.[5][27][4]
- Apr 2013 The board replaces Ron Johnson with Myron Ullman. The stock closes at $15.87.[6][24]
- May 2013 An ad asks shoppers to come back. A $2.25 billion loan secured on the company's property closes.[23][15][11][39]
- Aug 2013 The board backs the chairman against Ackman, who leaves the board. Pershing Square sells all its shares.[30][31][32]
- Sep 2013 JCPenney sells 84 million new shares at $9.65.[26]
Questions people ask
How many promotions did JCPenney run before Fair and Square?
JCPenney ran 590 separate promotions in 2011, a figure the AP later rounded to nearly 600[17][7].
Did JCPenney buy a stake in Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia?
Yes. On December 6, 2011, JCPenney bought 11 million new shares, 16.6% of the company, for $38.5 million[33]. Macy's, which had a 2006 deal with the brand, sued JCPenney in August 2012, and the case was settled in 2017[10][34].
Did JCPenney stop paying its dividend?
Yes. It ended its $0.20 quarterly dividend on May 15, 2012, saving about $175 million a year[9][4].
Who was JCPenney's president under Ron Johnson?
Michael Francis was JCPenney's president, and he left the company in June 2012 after about eight months[38].
Did JCPenney apologize to its customers?
In May 2013, after Ron Johnson left, JCPenney ran an ad asking customers to come back[23][15].
Who owned large stakes in JCPenney in 2010?
In October 2010, Pershing Square reported a 16.5% stake and Vornado Realty Trust reported 9.9%[28][35]. JCPenney adopted a one-year shareholder rights plan that month[36].
How did JCPenney do in the first quarter of 2013?
Comparable store sales fell 16.6% in the first quarter of 2013, and the company lost $348 million[39].
Sources
- jcpenney's transformation plans revealed at launch event in New York City, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (PR Newswire), 2012-01-25 Primary source
- J. C. Penney annual report (Form 10-K) for fiscal 2011, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-03-28 Primary source
- J. C. Penney quarterly report (Form 10-Q), quarter ended April 28, 2012, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-06-06 Primary source
- J. C. Penney annual report (Form 10-K) for fiscal 2013, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2014-03-21 Primary source
- Fourth quarter and full-year 2012 results (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-02-27 Primary source
- jcpenney appoints Myron E. (Mike) Ullman, III chief executive officer, succeeding Ron Johnson (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-04-08 Primary source
- J.C. Penney hopes to lure back customers with sales, Associated Press via NBC News (Anne D'Innocenzio), 2013-01-29
- J.C. Penney returns to coupons and marks up prices, ABC News (Susanna Kim), 2013-06-05
- First quarter 2012 results (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-05-15 Primary source
- J. C. Penney annual report (Form 10-K) for fiscal 2012, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-03-20 Primary source
- jcpenney announces consummation of $2.25 billion term loan (8-K exhibit 99.2), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-05-22 Primary source
- Second quarter 2012 results (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-08-10 Primary source
- Third quarter 2012 results (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-11-09 Primary source
- J. C. Penney quarterly report (Form 10-Q), quarter ended July 28, 2012, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-09-04 Primary source
- How to fail in business while really, really trying, Fortune (Jennifer Reingold), 2014-03-20
- J.C. Penney pricing disaster destroyed employee morale, HuffPost (Kim Bhasin), 2013-05-02
- Ron Johnson's Rx for J.C. Penney, Fortune (Jennifer Reingold), 2012-01-25
- What to expect: J.C. Penney's new pricing strategy, ABC News (Susanna Kim), 2012-01-31
- J. C. Penney Company names Ron Johnson as its next chief executive officer (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2011-06-14 Primary source
- Fourth quarter and full-year 2011 results (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-02-24 Primary source
- jcpenney simplifies business model to drive transformation, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (PR Newswire), 2012-04-05 Primary source
- J. C. Penney quarterly report (Form 10-Q), quarter ended May 4, 2013, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-06-11 Primary source
- J.C. Penney apologizes to customers, The Boston Globe, 2013-05-01
- JC Penney ousts CEO Ron Johnson, Associated Press via CBS News Texas, 2013-04-08
- jcpenney further strengthens financial position with $1.75 billion term loan (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-04-29 Primary source
- Prospectus supplement (Form 424B5) for 84,000,000 shares of common stock, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-09-30 Primary source
- Form 8-K: bondholders' notice of default and its withdrawal, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-03-20 Primary source
- Schedule 13D on J. C. Penney common stock, Pershing Square Capital Management (SEC EDGAR), 2010-10-08 Primary source
- Form 8-K: election of William A. Ackman and Steven Roth as directors, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2011-02-10 Primary source
- Statement of jcpenney's Board of Directors from Chairman Thomas Engibous (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-08-08 Primary source
- J. C. Penney announces changes to Board of Directors (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-08-13 Primary source
- Schedule 13D/A (Amendment No. 8): sale of all shares, Pershing Square Capital Management (SEC EDGAR), 2013-08-28 Primary source
- Schedule 13D on Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Class A common stock, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2011-12-16 Primary source
- Macy's, J.C. Penney settle Martha Stewart litigation, Reuters via Business Insurance, 2017-02-03
- Schedule 13D on J. C. Penney common stock, Vornado Realty Trust (SEC EDGAR), 2010-10-08 Primary source
- jcpenney adopts short-term stockholder rights plan (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2010-10-18 Primary source
- Third quarter 2011 results (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2011-11-14 Primary source
- jcpenney announces departure of Michael Francis (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-06-18 Primary source
- First quarter 2013 results (8-K exhibit 99.1), J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-05-16 Primary source