# Coca-Cola and New Coke, 1984 to 1985

1984 to 1985. Last updated October 12, 2026. https://hindsight.quest/history/coca-cola

New Coke was a sweeter Coca-Cola formula, announced on April 23, 1985, after blind tests with about 190,000 people favored it. It failed because many loyal drinkers wanted the original back, whatever the tests said. After weeks of protest calls, Coca-Cola brought the old formula back as Coca-Cola Classic on July 11, 1985.[1][2][3]

Play these decisions yourself in Hindsight: https://hindsight.quest/case/cocacola-taste-test?from=history

## Key figures

| Figure | Value | As of |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Blind taste tests before the change | About 190,000 [2][3] | 1985 |
| Years since the last formula change | 99 [1][2] | April 23, 1985 |
| Years of falling market share before the change | 15 [1] | 1985 |
| Hotline calls a day | 1,500, up from 400 [1][4][5] | June 1985 |
| Days until the original returned | 79 [1][3] | July 11, 1985 |
| Calls in the two days after Classic's return was announced | 31,600 [1] | July 1985 |

## What was New Coke?

New Coke was a sweeter formula of Coca-Cola that the company introduced in place of the original in 1985[3][6][2]. It was the first change to the recipe in 99 years[1][2].

The new formula stayed on sale after the original came back as Coca-Cola Classic in July 1985[1][7]. It was later renamed Coke II, in 1990 according to History.com and in 1992 according to The Henry Ford, and it was dropped in 2002[3][7].

## Why did Coca-Cola change its formula?

Coca-Cola changed its formula because its lead over Pepsi was shrinking and a sweeter recipe had beaten both colas in blind tests[2][3]. The company says its market share had been falling for 15 years in a row[1]. Pepsi had been promoting blind sip tests of its own in its Pepsi Challenge ads[2][3].

The company had already stretched the Coca-Cola name. Diet Coke came out in 1982[2][3][8], and caffeine-free Coke followed in 1983[2][8].

## How did Coca-Cola test New Coke before the launch?

Coca-Cola tested the new formula in blind taste tests with about 190,000 people[2][3]; the company puts the number at nearly 200,000[1]. Most preferred the sweeter formula to both the original Coca-Cola and Pepsi[2][3][9].

In the years before the change, Coca-Cola had also moved its sweetener from sugar to corn syrup[3][2][10].

## When did New Coke come out?

Chairman Roberto Goizueta announced the new formula on April 23, 1985, at a press conference at Lincoln Center in New York[3][2]. Pepsi gave its employees the day off[2][3].

The original recipe was to be locked in a bank vault in Atlanta and not used again[2][3]. Coca-Cola backed the new taste with a national TV campaign[2][5].

## How did people react to New Coke?

Many loyal drinkers protested. Calls to Coca-Cola's hotline rose from about 400 a day to 1,500 a day by June 1985[1][4][5], and the team answering them grew from about a dozen people to 180[11].

Protest groups formed, including Old Cola Drinkers of America[1][3]. Its leader was Gay Mullins of Seattle[4][6]. A lawsuit was filed in Seattle to force the company to bring the old taste back[3][12].

## Why did New Coke fail?

New Coke failed because the blind tests measured taste, not how people felt about losing the original. The company's own history and History.com both say the tests missed how attached drinkers were to the old Coca-Cola[1][3].

## When did Coca-Cola bring back the original formula?

Coca-Cola announced on July 11, 1985, 79 days after the change, that the original formula would return as Coca-Cola Classic[1][3]. The company took 31,600 calls in the two days after the announcement[1].

The news broke a day before the official announcement, on July 10[13][14]. The new formula stayed on the shelves beside Classic until 2002[7][3].

## The decisions, one by one

### Sep 1984: Change the recipe after the taste tests?

What Coca-Cola did: Approve the new formula.

Coca-Cola decided to change its formula for the first time in 99 years. Blind tests with more than 190,000 people from 1981 to 1984 preferred the sweeter taste 55% to 45% over the old one and 56% to 44% over Pepsi. The change was announced in April 1985.[2][1][3]

### Nov 1984: Switch the cola fully to corn syrup?

What Coca-Cola did: Switch fully to corn syrup.

In November 1984 Coca-Cola said bottled and canned Coca-Cola would be sweetened with 100% corn syrup; its fountain syrup had switched in May. Pepsi announced the same switch.[15][10][2]

### Mar 1985: Put our name on a cherry cola?

What Coca-Cola did: Launch the cherry cola.

Coca-Cola launched Cherry Coke in early 1985, a new product from an old soda-fountain idea. By 1987 it was one of the ten best-selling soft drinks in the country.[2][16]

## Timeline

- **1982** Diet Coke launches, the first new product to carry the Coca-Cola name; caffeine-free Coke follows in 1983. [2][8]
- **1981 to 1984** More than 190,000 people in 25 cities take blind tests of a new, sweeter formula. It beats the old one 55% to 45% and Pepsi 56% to 44%. [2][1]
- **Early 1985** Cherry Coke launches. [2][16]
- **Apr 23, 1985** Roberto Goizueta announces the first change to the formula in 99 years at Lincoln Center, New York. Pepsi gives its employees the day off. [1][2][3][17]
- **May 1985** Coke's sales rise 8% over May 1984; Pepsi says its sales rose 14%. An 18-month campaign, the costliest in the company's history, backs the new taste. [4][5][9]
- **Jun 1985** The hotline takes 1,500 calls a day, up from 400, and grows from about a dozen staff to 180. Gay Mullins's Old Cola Drinkers of America sues in Seattle; a federal judge dismisses the case on June 20. [1][11][4][12]
- **Jul 11, 1985** Coca-Cola announces the original will return as Coca-Cola Classic, beside the new Coke, 79 days after the change. Two days later it has taken 31,600 calls. [1][13][6]
- **Early 1990s to 2002** The new formula is renamed Coke II and is discontinued in 2002. [3][7]

## Questions people ask

### Who announced New Coke?

Roberto Goizueta, Coca-Cola's chairman and CEO, announced the new formula at Lincoln Center in New York on April 23, 1985[3][2].

### Was New Coke sweeter than the original Coca-Cola?

Yes. The new formula was sweeter than the old one[3][6][2].

### Was Cherry Coke part of the New Coke launch?

No. Cherry Coke was a separate product that also came out in 1985[2][16].

### Was Coca-Cola losing market share before New Coke?

Yes. Pepsi gained market share through the 1970s and early 1980s while Coca-Cola's share declined[3][1].

### Is New Coke still sold?

No. The new formula was renamed Coke II in the early 1990s and was discontinued in 2002[3][7].

## Sources

1. [New Coke: The Most Memorable Marketing Blunder Ever?, The Coca-Cola Company](https://www.coca-colacompany.com/about-us/history/new-coke-the-most-memorable-marketing-blunder-ever) (primary source)
2. [Fiddling with the Real Thing (John S. Demott), Time, 1985-05-06](https://time.com/archive/6712395/fiddling-with-the-real-thing/)
3. [Why Coca-Cola's 'New Coke' flopped (Christopher Klein), History.com, 2015-04-23](https://www.history.com/articles/why-coca-cola-new-coke-flopped)
4. [All Afizz Over the New Coke (John S. Demott), Time, 1985-06-24](https://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,959449-1,00.html)
5. [New Coke generates 40,000 calls, mostly negative (Charles S. Taylor), UPI, 1985-06-10](https://www.upi.com/Archives/1985/06/10/New-Coke-generates-40000-calls-mostly-negative/8900487224000/)
6. [30 years ago today, Coca-Cola made its worst mistake (Rachid Haoues), CBS News, 2015-04-23](https://www.cbsnews.com/news/30-years-ago-today-coca-cola-new-coke-failure/)
7. [New Coke: success or failure? (Donna R. Braden), The Henry Ford, 2015-04-23](https://www.thehenryford.org/collections/explore/articles/new-coke)
8. [Diet Coke, 7-Up argue over who's number three, UPI, 1984-03-07](https://www.upi.com/amp/Archives/1984/03/07/Diet-Coke-7-Up-argue-over-whos-number-three/7933447483600/)
9. [New Coke: the surprising fact about the legendary business fail (Lily Rothman), Time, 2015-04-23](https://time.com/3822869/new-coke-history/)
10. [Sugar Association says 'Classic' Coke still not real thing (Charles S. Taylor), UPI, 1985-08-14](https://www.upi.com/Archives/1985/08/14/Sugar-Association-says-Classic-coke-still-not-real-thing/8484492840000/)
11. [Veteran employees remember infamous 1985 launch of New Coke, The Coca-Cola Company, 2015-04-23](https://www.coca-colacompany.com/about-us/history/the-infamous-1985-launch-of-new-coke) (primary source)
12. [Suit to force Coke to restore its old taste fizzles, UPI, 1985-06-20](https://www.upi.com/Archives/1985/06/20/Suit-to-force-Coke-to-restore-its-old-taste-fizzles/5109488088000)
13. ['Old Coke' to return (Bill Lohmann), UPI, 1985-07-10](https://www.upi.com/Archives/1985/07/10/Old-Coke-to-return/9587489816000/)
14. [New Coke and Coca-Cola Classic: what the story says about America (James Cobb), Time, 2015-07-10](https://time.com/3950205/new-coke-history-america/)
15. [Pepsi, Coke turn to corn syrup, UPI, 1984-11-06](https://www.upi.com/Archives/1984/11/06/Pepsi-Coke-turn-to-corn-syrup/2049468565200/)
16. [Coca-Cola changes formula -- of Cherry Coke, UPI, 1987-01-29](https://www.upi.com/Archives/1987/01/29/Coca-Cola-changes-formula-of-Cherry-Coke/4960538894800/)
17. [New Coke debuts, one of the biggest product flops in history, History.com, 2024-04-22](https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/april-23/new-coke-debuts-one-of-the-biggest-product-flops-in-history)

---

Hindsight is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any company named.
