Company histories

How BlackBerry lost the smartphone race, 2007 to 2016

Research In Motion (RIM), maker of the BlackBerry, kept growing after Apple announced the iPhone in 2007, and revenue reached a record $19.9 billion in fiscal 2011. Its PlayBook tablet and BlackBerry 10 phones then left large charges on unsold stock. Revenue fell to $2.16 billion in fiscal 2016, and in September 2016, BlackBerry stopped designing its own phones.[1][2][3][4][5][6]

Real moments

Hindsight puts you in the CEO's chair at each of these decisions, with only what was known at the time. See how your calls compare with what BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did and how other players chose.

Play this decision

Key figures

FigureValueAs of
RIM revenue$3.0 billion[7]Fiscal 2007
BlackBerry subscriber accountsAbout 8 million[7]Fiscal 2007
RIM record revenue$19.9 billion[2]Fiscal 2011
Price paid for QNX Software Systems$200 million in cash[8][9]April 2010
Provision on unsold PlayBook tablets$485 million[3]December 2, 2011
Inventory charge, mostly Z10 phones$930 million to $960 million[4]September 2013
Fairfax-led letter of intent$9 a share, about $4.7 billion[10]September 23, 2013
BlackBerry net loss$5.9 billion[11]Fiscal 2014
BlackBerry revenue$2.16 billion[5]Fiscal 2016

How big was BlackBerry when the iPhone came out?

Research In Motion was a $3 billion company when the iPhone arrived. Apple announced the iPhone on January 9, 2007, with a touch keyboard, one US carrier and a June launch. Three months later, RIM reported $3.0 billion of revenue for fiscal 2007 and about 8 million subscriber accounts.[1][7]

RIM kept growing fast for four more years. Revenue reached $6.01 billion in fiscal 2008, $11.07 billion in fiscal 2009 and $14.95 billion in fiscal 2010, when it had over 41 million subscribers. Fiscal 2011 brought record revenue of $19.9 billion.[12][13][14][2]

How did BlackBerry respond to the iPhone?

RIM answered with the Storm, its first BlackBerry with a touch screen. RIM announced it on October 8, 2008, as an exclusive for Verizon Wireless in the US and for Vodafone, with a screen that clicks when pressed.[15]

By then, Apple had moved on. The iPhone 3G went on sale in July 2008 at $199, with Microsoft Exchange email and the App Store.[16]

The Storm reached Verizon stores on November 21, 2008, at $199.99 after a rebate. Reviews were mixed, and several reviewers found its software slow.[17][18][19]

Why did BlackBerry buy QNX?

RIM bought QNX to get a new operating system, and QNX became the base of its PlayBook tablet and later of BlackBerry 10. RIM agreed in April 2010 to buy QNX Software Systems from Harman International for $200 million in cash, and the deal closed on June 1, 2010.[8][9][20]

Tablets had just become a new market. Apple said on May 3, 2010, that it had sold one million iPads in 28 days. RIM unveiled the PlayBook, built on QNX, on September 27, 2010.[21][22][23]

Why did the BlackBerry PlayBook fail?

The PlayBook went on sale without its own email, calendar or contacts apps, and RIM was left with stock it could not sell. It launched on April 19, 2011, at prices from $499, and reviewers pointed out the missing email. Those apps arrived only with a software update on February 21, 2012.[24][25][26]

RIM shipped about 500,000 PlayBooks in its first quarter on sale. On December 2, 2011, it announced a $485 million provision on PlayBook inventory.[27][3]

What happened during the 2011 BlackBerry outage?

In October 2011, a network failure cut BlackBerry email, messaging and web service for about three days. It started outside North America and spread to users in the US and Canada on its third day.[28][29]

On October 17, 2011, RIM offered free premium apps worth more than $100 to its customers, whom it put at more than 70 million.[30]

Who replaced BlackBerry's co-CEOs?

Thorsten Heins, RIM's chief operating officer, replaced co-CEOs Mike Lazaridis and Jim Balsillie on January 22, 2012. The board named him president and CEO on the co-CEOs' own recommendation. Lazaridis became vice chair, Barbara Stymiest became independent chair, and Balsillie left the board in March 2012.[31][32]

Investors had pressed for a change months earlier. In June 2011, a shareholder proposal and several large investors pushed RIM to split the chair and CEO roles that the two co-CEOs shared.[33][34]

When did BlackBerry 10 come out?

BlackBerry 10 launched on January 30, 2013, on the all-touch Z10 and the Q10 with a keyboard. On the same day, Research In Motion renamed itself BlackBerry.[35]

The launch came later than planned. On June 28, 2012, RIM said the first BlackBerry 10 phones would slip to early 2013, reported a $518 million quarterly loss and planned about 5,000 job cuts.[36]

The new phones did not stop the decline. Revenue for fiscal 2013 fell 40% to $11.1 billion. In September 2013, BlackBerry announced an inventory charge of $930 million to $960 million, mostly for Z10 phones, and about 4,500 job cuts.[37][4]

Was BlackBerry sold in 2013?

No. BlackBerry agreed to a possible sale in 2013, but the buyout never happened. On August 12, 2013, its board formed a special committee to explore strategic alternatives. On September 23, it signed a letter of intent with a consortium led by Fairfax Financial, which owned about 10% of BlackBerry, at $9 a share, about $4.7 billion.[38][10]

On November 4, 2013, BlackBerry took a $1 billion convertible investment from Fairfax and other investors instead. Thorsten Heins stepped down, and John Chen became executive chair and interim CEO.[39][40]

Revenue kept falling. For fiscal 2014, revenue fell to $6.8 billion, and BlackBerry reported a net loss of $5.9 billion.[11]

When did BlackBerry stop making phones?

BlackBerry said on September 28, 2016, that it would end all internal hardware development and hand it to partners. It had just signed its first deal licensing BlackBerry-branded phones, with a joint venture in Indonesia. Software and services made up 44% of revenue that quarter.[6]

The year before, BlackBerry had made two other big moves. On September 4, 2015, it agreed to buy Good Technology for $425 million. On September 25, 2015, John Chen confirmed a BlackBerry phone running Google's Android, while promising more BlackBerry 10 updates. Revenue fell to $3.3 billion in fiscal 2015 and $2.16 billion in fiscal 2016.[41][42][43][5]

The decisions, one by one

  1. Late 2008

    Answer the touchscreen phone with a touch phone of our own?

    What BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did Build the touch phone.

    Research In Motion (RIM) announced the Storm, its first touch-screen BlackBerry, with a screen that clicks, on October 8, 2008, as an exclusive for Verizon Wireless and Vodafone. It went on sale at Verizon on November 21 for $199.99 after a rebate. Reviews were mixed; several found the software slow.[15][17][18][19]

  2. Apr 2010

    Buy an OS maker, or adopt the open OS?

    What BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did Buy the OS maker.

    RIM agreed in April 2010 to buy QNX Software Systems from Harman International for $200 million in cash; the deal closed on June 1. QNX became the base of the PlayBook tablet, announced that September, and of the next generation of BlackBerry phones.[8][9][20][22][23][3]

  3. Apr 2011

    Ship the tablet without its own email?

    What BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did Ship it in April.

    RIM launched the PlayBook on April 19, 2011, from $499. It had no built-in email, calendar or contacts until an update on February 21, 2012. RIM shipped about 500,000 in the first quarter and took a $485 million provision on unsold PlayBooks in December 2011.[24][25][26][27][3]

  4. Jan 2012

    Hand the top job to the insider, or bring in an outsider?

    What BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did Promote the operating chief.

    On January 22, 2012, RIM's board, acting on the co-CEOs' recommendation, named chief operating officer Thorsten Heins president and CEO. Mike Lazaridis became vice chair and Barbara Stymiest independent chair; Jim Balsillie left the board in March. Shareholders had pushed to split the roles in June 2011.[31][32][33][34][28]

  5. Jun 2012

    Delay the new phones to 2013?

    What BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did Delay to 2013 and cut costs.

    RIM said on June 28, 2012, that the first BlackBerry 10 phones would slip to early 2013, reported a $518 million quarterly loss and planned about 5,000 job cuts. BlackBerry 10 launched on January 30, 2013, on the all-touch Z10 and the keyboard Q10, and RIM renamed itself BlackBerry.[36][35]

  6. May 2013

    Open our messenger to rivals' phones?

    What BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did Open it to every phone.

    BlackBerry announced on May 14, 2013, that BBM, which had more than 60 million monthly users, would come to iOS and Android. It launched there in October 2013 with more than 10 million downloads on the first day.[44][45]

  7. Sep 2013

    Sell to the consortium at $9 a share?

    What BlackBerry (Research In Motion) did Sign the $9-a-share deal.

    BlackBerry signed a letter of intent on September 23, 2013, with a Fairfax-led consortium at $9 a share, about $4.7 billion. No buyout followed. On November 4 it took a $1 billion convertible investment instead; Thorsten Heins stepped down and John Chen became executive chair and interim CEO.[38][10][4][39][40]

Timeline

  1. Jan 2007 Apple announces the iPhone, with a touch keyboard and one US carrier, for June.[1]
  2. Apr 2007 RIM reports $3.0 billion of revenue for fiscal 2007 and about 8 million subscriber accounts.[7]
  3. Jul 2008 The iPhone 3G goes on sale at $199 with Exchange email and the App Store.[16]
  4. Oct 2008 RIM announces the Storm, its first touch-screen BlackBerry, for Verizon Wireless and Vodafone.[15]
  5. Nov 2008 The Storm goes on sale at Verizon for $199.99 after a rebate, to mixed reviews.[17][18][19]
  6. Apr 2008 RIM ends fiscal 2008 with $6.01 billion of revenue and over 14 million subscribers.[12]
  7. Apr 2009 RIM ends fiscal 2009 with $11.07 billion of revenue and about 25 million subscribers.[13]
  8. Apr 2010 RIM reports $14.95 billion of revenue and over 41 million subscribers, and agrees to buy QNX for $200 million.[14][8][9]
  9. May 2010 Apple sells one million iPads in 28 days.[21]
  10. Sep 2010 RIM unveils the PlayBook tablet, built on QNX.[22][23]
  11. Mar 2011 RIM ends fiscal 2011 with record revenue of $19.9 billion.[2]
  12. Apr 2011 The PlayBook goes on sale from $499, without its own email app.[24][25]
  13. Jun 2011 Shareholders push RIM to split the chair and CEO roles held by its two co-CEOs.[33][34]
  14. Oct 2011 A three-day network outage hits BlackBerry users; RIM offers more than $100 of free apps.[28][29][30]
  15. Dec 2011 RIM takes a $485 million provision on unsold PlayBooks.[3]
  16. Jan 2012 Thorsten Heins replaces co-CEOs Mike Lazaridis and Jim Balsillie.[31]
  17. Jun 2012 BlackBerry 10 slips to 2013; RIM plans about 5,000 job cuts.[36]
  18. Jan 2013 BlackBerry 10 launches on the Z10 and Q10, and RIM renames itself BlackBerry.[35]
  19. Mar 2013 Fiscal 2013 revenue falls 40% to $11.1 billion; subscribers number about 76 million.[37]
  20. May 2013 BlackBerry says BBM will come to iOS and Android; it launches there in October.[44][45]
  21. Sep 2013 A charge of up to $960 million on unsold phones, 4,500 job cuts, and a $9-a-share letter of intent with a Fairfax-led group.[4][10]
  22. Nov 2013 No buyout: a $1 billion convertible investment, and John Chen becomes executive chair and interim CEO.[39]
  23. Dec 2013 BlackBerry signs a five-year manufacturing partnership with Foxconn.[46]
  24. Mar 2014 Fiscal 2014 revenue falls to $6.8 billion, with a net loss of $5.9 billion.[11]
  25. Mar 2015 Fiscal 2015 revenue falls to $3.3 billion.[43]
  26. Sep 2015 BlackBerry agrees to buy Good Technology for $425 million and confirms an Android phone.[41][42]
  27. Nov 2015 The Android-based Priv goes on sale at AT&T for $699.[47][48]
  28. Sep 2016 BlackBerry says it will stop designing phones and outsource hardware to partners.[6]

Questions people ask

How many BlackBerry subscribers were there in 2012?

RIM reported more than 77 million subscribers at the end of fiscal 2012, in March 2012. A year later, the count was about 76 million.[32][37]

When did Research In Motion change its name to BlackBerry?

The company renamed itself BlackBerry on January 30, 2013, the day it launched BlackBerry 10.[35]

When did BBM come to iPhone and Android?

BlackBerry said on May 14, 2013, that BBM, which then had more than 60 million monthly users, would come to iOS and Android. It launched there in October 2013 and passed 10 million downloads on its first day.[44][45]

Did BlackBerry make an Android phone?

Yes. The Priv, a slider phone with a keyboard that ran Android, went on sale at AT&T in the US on November 6, 2015, for $699.[47][48][42]

What was BlackBerry's deal with Foxconn?

On December 20, 2013, BlackBerry announced a five-year manufacturing partnership with Foxconn.[46]

How much did BlackBerry pay for Good Technology?

BlackBerry agreed on September 4, 2015, to buy Good Technology for $425 million.[41]

Play this decision

Sources

  1. Apple Reinvents the Phone with iPhone, Apple Newsroom, 2007-01-09 Primary source
  2. RIM reports fourth quarter and year-end results for fiscal 2011 (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2011-03-25 Primary source
  3. RIM announces third quarter provision related to PlayBook inventory (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2011-12-02 Primary source
  4. BlackBerry announces preliminary second quarter fiscal 2014 results and provides business update (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-09-23 Primary source
  5. BlackBerry reports software and services growth for Q4 and fiscal 2016 (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2016-04-01 Primary source
  6. BlackBerry reports Q2 fiscal 2017 results and a new strategic direction for mobility solutions (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2016-09-28 Primary source
  7. RIM reports preliminary fourth quarter and year-end results for fiscal 2007 (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2007-04-17 Primary source
  8. Research In Motion to Acquire QNX Software Unit from Harman International (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2010-04-13 Primary source
  9. Harman International quarterly report (Form 10-Q) for the quarter ended March 31, 2010, Harman International (SEC EDGAR), 2010-04-29 Primary source
  10. BlackBerry Enters into Letter of Intent with Consortium led by Fairfax Financial (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-09-23 Primary source
  11. BlackBerry reports fourth quarter and year-end results for fiscal 2014 (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2014-03-28 Primary source
  12. RIM reports fourth quarter and year-end results for fiscal 2008 (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2008-04-03 Primary source
  13. RIM reports fourth quarter and year-end results for fiscal 2009 (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2009-04-03 Primary source
  14. RIM reports year-end and fourth quarter results for fiscal 2010 (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2010-04-01 Primary source
  15. BlackBerry Takes the World by Storm with Verizon Wireless and Vodafone (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2008-10-09 Primary source
  16. Apple Introduces the New iPhone 3G, Apple Newsroom, 2008-06-09 Primary source
  17. Verizon BlackBerry Storm Officially $199 on Nov. 21, Gizmodo, 2008-11-13
  18. Storm Ahead: Verizon Sets a Date and Price for the Touch-Screen BlackBerry, Technologizer, 2008-11-13
  19. BlackBerry Storm: The reviews are in, Fortune, 2008-11-20
  20. Harman International annual report (Form 10-K) for fiscal 2010, Harman International (SEC EDGAR), 2010-08-06 Primary source
  21. Apple Sells One Million iPads, Apple Newsroom, 2010-05-03 Primary source
  22. RIM announces BlackBerry 'PlayBook' tablet, Associated Press via NBC News, 2010-09-27
  23. RIM Outs The PlayBook BlackBerry Tablet, TechCrunch, 2010-09-27
  24. Best Buy Begins Accepting Orders for BlackBerry PlayBook Today (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2011-03-22 Primary source
  25. BlackBerry PlayBook review roundup, Christian Science Monitor, 2011-04-14
  26. RIM belatedly updates PlayBook with email app, Associated Press via NBC News, 2012-02-21
  27. RIM reports first quarter fiscal 2012 results (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2011-06-17 Primary source
  28. BlackBerry outages persist into third day, spread to North America, Associated Press via Phys.org, 2011-10-12
  29. BlackBerry Maker Scrambles to End Global Outage; Repair Damage to Brand, Reuters via Insurance Journal, 2011-10-13
  30. Research In Motion Offers Free Premium Apps to Customers Following Service Interruptions (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2011-10-18 Primary source
  31. Research In Motion Names Thorsten Heins President and CEO (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2012-01-23 Primary source
  32. RIM reports fourth quarter and year-end results for fiscal 2012 (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2012-03-30 Primary source
  33. RIM Shareholder Seeks Change to Top of Corporate Org Chart, AllThingsD, 2011-06-10
  34. Demands grow for RIM leadership split, Bloomberg via Taipei Times, 2011-06-19
  35. BlackBerry 10 launch and name change to BlackBerry (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-01-31 Primary source
  36. RIM reports first quarter fiscal 2013 results (Form 6-K), Research In Motion (SEC EDGAR), 2012-06-29 Primary source
  37. BlackBerry reports fourth quarter and year-end results for fiscal 2013 (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-03-28 Primary source
  38. BlackBerry Board of Directors Announces Exploration of Strategic Alternatives (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-08-12 Primary source
  39. BlackBerry Receives Investment of U.S. $1 Billion from Fairfax Financial and Other Institutional Investors (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-11-04 Primary source
  40. BlackBerry Takes $1B Investment From Fairfax, Others, Replaces CEO Thorsten Heins, TechCrunch, 2013-11-04
  41. BlackBerry to Acquire Good Technology (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2015-09-04 Primary source
  42. BlackBerry second quarter fiscal 2016 results and Android device announcement (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2015-09-25 Primary source
  43. BlackBerry reports results for the fiscal 2015 fourth quarter (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2015-03-27 Primary source
  44. BBM for iOS and Android to Launch This Summer (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-05-15 Primary source
  45. Over 10 Million Downloads of BBM for Android and iPhone in the First Day (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-10-23 Primary source
  46. BlackBerry Announces Five-Year Strategic Partnership with Foxconn (Form 6-K), BlackBerry (SEC EDGAR), 2013-12-20 Primary source
  47. BlackBerry PRIV launching in the US on AT&T this Friday, November 6, 9to5Google, 2015-11-02
  48. AT&T to Sell BlackBerry Priv November 6, Phone Scoop, 2015-11-02